Maybelline Products Review

Written by Mona Hadi Naeem
10 · 05 · 17
Maybelline Products Review

It has been ages since I wrote or shared a Maybelline products review, so here is more. Based on personal experience and completely unbiased. I want to share my personal rating on thirteen products I liked. So here goes …

Maybelline Products Review Countdown

#13: Maybelline New York Cool Effect Cooling Shadow/Liner

Price: $5.99

Average rating out of 10: 8.1

Reasons: True to its name, the Cool Effect eye shadow from Maybelline New York is so smooth that it truly makes the lids feel cool, which can be a boon for day makeup. Although all the shades are unique, a popular favorite is the ‘Chill the Champagne’ shade, one that works as well for night makeup as for the day. Several customers have confessed to being devoted fans of this shade, and the shade is just one reason. One of the great things about this particular shade is that it can double as a lipstick base because of its cooling effect and great staying power. The amazing composition also prevents the layer from cracking up or forming creases. Thus, your eyes will look as smooth as natural skin all day long. The only thing you need to be careful about is to use small amounts since a little goes a long way.

#12: Maybelline New York Lip Polish Lip Gloss

Price: $5.79

Average rating out of 10: 8.2

Reasons: Lip Polish is a great product from Maybelline New York that checks almost every item on the list. Any Maybelline products review will back this up. Most importantly, it is extremely comfortable to wear throughout the day because it is quite non-sticky and light. It has a very smooth texture and gives finesse to the lips. It is also quite fragrant without being overpowering. The colour is well balanced and it goes well with different styles of makeup. In fact, it is gentle on the lips, so you do not need to worry about applying it several times during the day.

#11: Maybelline New York Expert Eyes 100% Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover

Price: $4.59

Average rating out of 10: 8.3

Reasons: As the name suggests, the Expert Eyes remover feels extremely light on the skin and leaves absolutely no residue, clearing away all the eye makeup—eye shadow, mascara, everything’s gone in one sweep. It does not feel heavy or greasy on the skin, allowing the skin to breathe after hours of makeup application. Expert Eyes is a time-tested product. Women have been cleaning eye makeup with Expert Eyes for several years and it has remained a consistent product on the market. Not to mention, at less than $5 it is a steal and must-have in every makeup kit. Because it does not contain any synthetic oils, Expert Eyes is ideal for sensitive eyes and for women who wear contacts. Its formulation produces gentle cleansing without irritating the delicate tissues around the eyes.

#10: Maybelline New York Dream Matte Powder

Price: $5.75

Average rating out of 10: 8.3

Reasons: Maybelline New York’s awesome Dream Matte powder is a blockbuster from the get-go. A deceptively simple everyday product, Dream Matte is actually extremely good quality. It offers very smooth consistency and covers the finest of lines without giving a cakey look. It is not heavy so your skin can breathe comfortably during application. Not only does it offer greater coverage than other products, but also it is more enduring and stays for several hours. That is good if you like to apply it over your foundation. Customers find that when they apply makeup over Dream Matte, it blends perfectly nicely without creating patches of uneven color. Customers are also madly in love with the design of the case. It comes in a double-compartment swivel case—one for the pressed powder and another for the applicator. The applicator is also of good quality as it is feels gentle on the skin and does not have any rough fibres. This is an honest and personal Maybelline products review.

#9: Maybelline New York Instant Age Rewind Double Face Perfector

Price: $6.38

Average rating out of 10: 8.4

Reasons: The Instant Age Rewind Double Face Perfector is Maybelline New York’s solution to puffed up eyes and dark circles. One can apply it very conveniently all over and around the eyelids, including corners and the under-eye areas that can be tricky. Priced at an affordable $6.38, it offers greater value than other brands because of its excellent coverage and smooth blending. The highlighter component is extremely popular among consumers because it also acts as an effective eye shadow base. As a concealer, the Instant Age Rewind does what it is supposed to do—concealing dark spots and pigmented areas, hiding dark circles and reducing puffy eyes. The overall effect that this produces is amazing since it covers up any visible flaws in the skin, taking away several years from the face. The face perfector has good coverage, which is why it also lasts longer. Blending the product on the skin also poses no problems at all since it blends evenly without producing a patchy appearance. Consumers who have tried the product vouch for its strong qualities such as its ability to get the perfect morning look in very little time.

#8: Maybelline New York Expert Wear Eye Shadow Duos

Price: $4.49

Average rating out of 10: 8.5

Reasons: If you want a single eye shadow palette that offers amazingly contrasting color combinations you can actually use, then the Expert Wear Eye Shadow from Maybelline New York has to be it. On a single palette, you get an eye shadow and an accompanying highlighter for less than $5.00. The best part is that both the components have a light feel and blend smoothly into each other. The product has a creamy consistency without being overly greasy, which does not dampen the skin. At the same time, the product is long lasting and durable. The result leaves your eyelids looking absolutely smashing—well blended, bright and luminous. One of the bestselling shades is Grey Matters since it works well to achieve a contouring effect and creates awesome smoky eyes. The range also comes in brighter shades that go well with light-coloured eyes and bright makeup, helping the eyes stand out prominently. The product also comes with a high-quality applicator that ensures even application and smooth blending of the powder. Trust my Maybelline products review and try this eye shadow once at least.

#7: Maybelline New York Expert Wear Stay-True Bronzer

Price: $5.49

Average rating out of 10: 8.5

Reasons: Bronzers are typically challenging products to use because creating the perfect tanned skin tone is not easy. Maybelline New York’s Expert Wear Stay-True Bronzer has been a regular winner with consumers and product reviewers. Regarded as one of the best bronzers on the market, this is a must-have product to create a summer look any time of the year. The Expert Wear Stay-True Bronzer complements most skin types to give a natural tanned look. It is a great alternative to the typical blushed look, which looks unreal and artificial most of the time. It applies smoothly and gives a lot of coverage, so one must take care not to over-apply it. Even a little quantity of the bronzer is perfect for a natural, bronze tone.

#6:  Maybelline New York Pure Stay Powder Foundation

Price: $8.32

Average rating out of 10: 8.6

Reasons: A common problem with using powder foundations is that they seem too dry and flaky. But the Pure Stay Powder Foundation from Maybelline New York is a welcome exception. With a smooth texture that provides the right amount of moisture to keep your makeup in place, Pure Stay is one of the best products in its category. The product suits all skin types, especially oily skin, since its light consistency allows the skin pores to breathe and without clogging with oil and dirt. It is a thoroughly non-greasy product and stays where it is supposed to stay. It does not leave the skin looking shiny, nor does it stain clothes.

#5: Maybelline New York Salon Expert Nail Color

Price: $4.5

Average rating out of 10: 8.6

Reasons: Ever had your nail color come off after brushing your nails against a rough surface, or simply washing your hands with soap? Well, Maybelline New York’s Salon Expert Nail Color will not let that happen anymore. Made with a special formula that helps the nail color to stay on the nails for longer and to resist chemical agents and shocks, this line of professional quality nail colors has become a hit with users everywhere. The secret does not lie in the formulation alone. The specially designed applicator brush enables you to apply the nail color evenly, without creating lumps or running over your cuticles. The line comes in a series of eye-popping colors that go with all styles of makeup and jewelry. In fact, Salon Expert Nail Color gives your nails a certain sheen that makes applying a nail shine unnecessary.

#4: Maybelline New York Mineral Power Naturally Luminous Blush

Price: $8.49

Average rating out of 10: 8.8

Reasons: What is it that you look for in a blush? Ease of application. A natural shade that complements your skin tone. Smooth blending. Long lasting. Gentle on the skin. What if one blush had it all? Do not be surprised. Maybelline New York’s Mineral Power Naturally Luminous Blush offers all these benefits for all skin tones. Compared with more expensive brands, this product looks simple but gives a look that is nothing but professional. It imparts a very natural, gentle hue of pink to the cheeks that complements light as well as tanned skin tones. It comes with an easy to use applicator brush that allows the powder to distribute evenly across the skin surface. The product offers to trouble when it comes to blending either. The result being that you get a perfectly natural looking glow that seems to emerge from within your skin rather than appearing to have been slopped onto it. Mineral Power Naturally Luminous Blush is a long-lasting product, which means that once you have applied it in the morning, you can forget about it for the rest of the day. It will not come off unless you want it to, and you won’t have to rush to the restroom to apply another coat.

#3: Maybelline New York Lash Discovery Mini-Brush Washable Mascara

Price: $6.99

Average rating out of 10: 8.9

Reasons: A full and dark set of lashes frames the eyes perfectly. However, what do you do when your mascara does not apply evenly or makes your lashes feel thick and heavy as lead? The answer is Maybelline New York’s Lash Discovery. This washable mascara comes with a special mini-brush, which makes even application of the product a no-brainer. Made with a special, light formulation, this mascara does not make your lashes feel heavy after application. It has a smooth texture, which makes it easier to spread on all lashes, providing maximum coverage to every single lash. Your eyes look fresh and stay perfect throughout the day. It is as easy to clean away as it is to apply. A little water is all you need to clear away the product completely.

#2: Maybelline New York Ultra-Brow Brush-On Color

Price: $5.79

Average rating out of 10: 8.9

Reasons: A good eyebrow color stick should add volume to light eyebrows and make them add to the beauty of the face. The Ultra-Brow Brush-On eyebrow color from Maybelline New York does just that. With an ideal texture that holds nicely to the brow without fading or smudging, this product adds the right volume to your brows and makes them stand out. Moreover, it gives a completely natural look that no eyebrow pencil can help to achieve. Application is smooth as the product blends smoothly with the existing growth. A single application lasts throughout the day without the need for repeated touch-ups.

#1: Maybelline New York Color Sensational Lipcolor

Price: $7.50

Average rating out of 10: 9.2

Reasons: Color Sensational Lipcolor from Maybelline New York is by far the most popular lip product from the cosmetics giant. It’s trendy and, at $7.50, pretty economical for a drugstore product. However, these are not the real reasons for its appeal. The product is popular because of its smooth texture and its ability to stay for a good number of hours without feeling greasy or sticky. Consumers are wild about the wide range of shades that the product is available in—48 amazing shades to be precise.

What makes the product remarkable against other competing brands is the relatively high proportion of pigment to carrier compounds. In contrasts to other lip colors that contain just 7% pigment, the Color Sensational Lip Color contains 12%, nearly twice as much. This gives the user a truly deep shade that has higher visibility than traditional lip colors. The product is also economical because due to the intense shades, there remains no need to apply a topcoat. No wonder then that the product has been unbeaten for years in a row and consumers continue to demand it.

Our Maybelline products review comes to an end with this for now. Hope you share your reviews in the comments down below!

Click here to read our previous post “The Makeup Items Every Woman Needs to Add to Her Kit” in case you missed it. To read more about amazing lifestyle tips, keep visiting us on We are all you need for a great and happy lifestyle!

More Like This

Related Posts


Mona Hadi Naeem